An overdraft that exceeds the authorized limit and a payment debited without the account holder’s consent are governed by two separate sets of rules. The deadlines for bringing one back into good standing or disputing the other do not overlap, and confusing them can mean losing your rights. This article compares these two situations, their respective deadlines and the practical consequences for the account holder.
Unauthorized overdraft vs. unauthorized payment: deadline comparison table
| Criterion | Unauthorized bank overdraft | Unauthorized payment transaction |
|---|---|---|
| Definition | Negative balance exceeding the amount or duration set out in the account agreement | Direct debit, card payment or transfer made without a valid mandate from the customer |
| Deadline to bring the account back into good standing or dispute the transaction | No fixed statutory deadline: the bank can require the balance to be brought back above zero at any time, with a critical threshold at 3 months | 13 months from the debit date (70 days if the payee is outside the EU/EEA) |
| Bank’s obligation to reimburse | Not applicable: the customer owes the bank | No later than the end of the business day following the day the bank becomes aware of the dispute |
| Risk of being listed on a credit register | Possible listing on the FCC or FICP following repeated incidents or an overdraft lasting more than 3 months | No listing resulting from the dispute itself |
The distinction is crucial. The repayment deadline for an unauthorized overdraft depends largely on the bank’s policy and the signed account agreement, whereas the deadline for disputing an unauthorized transaction is set by law.

Unauthorized bank overdraft: what happens after 30 days and after 3 months
When an account remains overdrawn beyond its authorized limit (or when no overdraft facility has been authorized), the bank charges interest at the debit rate set out in the account agreement. This rate is generally higher than the rate for an authorized overdraft, but cannot exceed the applicable usury rate.
How the consequences escalate over time
During the first few weeks, the bank charges interest and may apply intervention fees for each transaction that takes the already overdrawn account further into the red. After 30 days without bringing the overdraft back into good standing, the consequences become more serious.
- The bank may refuse transactions (checks, direct debits, card payments), resulting in additional rejection fees for the customer
- A formal demand letter is often sent, requiring the account to be brought back above zero within a specified period
- If the overdraft continues for more than 3 months, the law requires the bank to make the customer an offer of consumer credit, effectively converting the debt into an amortizing loan with a repayment schedule
This reclassification as consumer credit after 3 months is provided for by the French Consumer Code. Ordinance No. 2025-880 of September 3, 2025 strengthens these rules: from November 20, 2026, even authorized overdrafts of less than 200 euros or lasting less than one month will be subject to consumer credit rules, with a mandatory creditworthiness assessment before any new authorization is granted.
The risk of being listed on the FICP (the register of credit repayment incidents) arises when the bank reports a qualifying incident. The listing lasts for up to five years and makes it harder to obtain any new credit.
Unauthorized payment on your statement: dispute deadlines and bank reimbursement
Unauthorized overdrafts and unauthorized payments are often confused when reviewing a bank statement: the customer sees a negative balance and assumes they are overdrawn, when in fact the balance is due to a direct debit or card payment they never approved.
13-month deadline and reimbursement by the next business day
For a payment transaction made without a valid mandate, the customer has 13 months from the debit date to report it. The bank must then reimburse the disputed amount no later than the end of the business day following receipt of the claim. A CJEU ruling of October 15, 2026, reported by Service-Public, clarifies that the customer’s gross negligence alone is not enough to delay this reimbursement.
The bank may subsequently seek to recover the amount if it establishes that the customer acted with gross negligence or committed fraud. If it has serious grounds to suspect fraud, it may refuse the initial reimbursement, provided it gives its reasons in writing to the competent national authority.
Transfers approved under pressure from a scammer: a special case
When the account holder personally approves a transfer under pressure or as a result of a scammer’s manipulation (for example, the fake bank adviser scam), the transaction is considered “authorized” in technical terms. The reimbursement-by-the-next-business-day rule does not apply in this case. The European ruling of October 2026 does not cover these so-called authorized transfers. The transaction can still be disputed, but a different procedure applies, and it often takes longer.

Bank complaint: choose the right procedure based on the cause of the negative balance
When faced with an unexpected negative balance, the first step is to check the nature of each debit on the statement. An unrecognized direct debit and a card limit being exceeded are handled differently.
- If the negative balance is due to exceeding the authorized overdraft limit or a buildup of spending, it is an unauthorized overdraft: the customer must bring the account back into good standing by adding funds, negotiate a repayment schedule or wait for it to be reclassified as consumer credit after 3 months
- If the negative balance results from a direct debit without a valid mandate or a fraudulent card payment, it is an unauthorized transaction: the customer must send the bank a written dispute within 13 months, stating the transaction date and exact amount
- If the negative balance involves both situations (an existing overdraft made worse by a fraudulent transaction), each part must be handled separately under its own rules
In all cases, keeping statements, letters and proof of receipt protects the customer if the dispute drags on. The banking ombudsman can be contacted free of charge if the bank does not respond within two months or if the customer is dissatisfied with its response.
A negative balance on a statement does not have just one cause or one set of legal rules. The difference between reimbursement by the next business day (for an unauthorized transaction) and bringing an account back into good standing with no fixed statutory deadline (for an unauthorized overdraft) can mean several weeks, or even months, of proceedings. Correctly identifying the nature of the debit is the first step to take before making a complaint.



